Hold harmless clauses can drastically increase an ophthalmologist’s potential professional liability by making it possible for either party to the contract to recover the damages against the other in actions which otherwise could not be sustained. Indemnity or hold harmless provisions in contracts are interpreted according to the general rules governing the formation, validity and construction of all contracts. • Consent Forms, • Policy Information In most cases, ophthalmologists will find their insurance policies do not cover the unlimited liabilities that can be assumed by the physician under a contract containing a hold harmless clause. They may even be used in a medical setting, between a physician and a patient. The hold harmless agreement template is used in multiple industries like sports, contractors, and construction. • Application Forms, • Seminars and Courses Do not ignore an indemnity clause and assume it can be resolved at a future date. competent to sign this Release, Hold Harmless, and Indemnification Agreement (“Agreement”). • Insurance 101 The words “hold harmless” and “indemnify” do not have to be in the contract clause to create a duty to indemnify. Potamkin L, Plotka NL. • Hotline third-party claims by agreeing to “indemnify and hold harmless” the other party for certain types of claims under limited circumstances. hbspt.cta._relativeUrls=true;hbspt.cta.load(508142, '35fb4f75-fa17-4779-a029-6a0441b4a787', {}); 1. The group was surprised to find themselves in a situation in which the group’s assets could be at risk. It protects the sports com… A hold harmless clause is a statement in a contract that absolves one or both parties to the agreement from liability for any injuries or damage. Managing Risk on the Business Side of Medicine, Over-Utilizing Medical Externs Leads to Allegation of Improper Supervision, Understanding the Risks Associated with Medical Directorships, Inadequate Screening of Clinicians and Staff, False Advertising of a Medical Practice Leads to Allegations of Fraud, Granting Patient Refund Requests: Risks and Benefits, Law and Emergency Medicine: Indemnification Clauses in Emergency Physician Contracts, Indemnification in Healthcare Contracts: Concepts, Coverage and Clauses, Learn more about the NORCAL Group of companies. Abstract. Discrimination and precision in choosing words is essential to achieving protection from far-reaching liability provisions. The undersigned hereby agrees to indemnify, save harmless, and waives liability of the … They also had not connected the indemnity clause to the exclusion in their medical liability policy. We also use cookies to analyze our website's traffic using a third party partner (Google Analytics), but we make your IP address anonymous before sharing it with them. Some clauses only require the physician/indemnitor to indemnify the third party/indemnitee for claims resulting from the physician’s own negligence. Using the above example, the group may also agree to indemnify the physician. Essentially this means that the indemnifying party agrees to reimburse … Sometimes such contract provisions are one-sided, where only one party indemnifies the other; in other cases, the contract provides cross or mutual indemnification where both parties indemnify each other. * NORCAL Group includes NORCAL Mutual Insurance Company and its affiliated companies. • 8 1/2" x 11"(detached) • 2 part snap set, carbonless white paper, black ink • 5 hole punched top and side • Wrapped 100s August 26, 2019. Such clauses generally come in two forms, while a third type is often confused as a hold harmless … In addition, physicians should ask an attorney to prepare a standard clause to replace all overreaching indemnification provisions to which the provider is a party. If you are currently in an agreement containing a hold harmless clause, don’t panic. Suppose you are a property owner who rents out a warehouse and one of the workers at the warehouse is injured on the property or a worker breaks a piece of equipment. July/Aug 2012; 19(4):7. An emergency department (ED) physician was part of a group that contracted with a hospital to provide emergency medicine services to patients. An HHA should … When a physician signs a contract to join a medical group, and the contract has indemnification language, the physician … But the nature of malpractice litigation can undermine any apparent obligation this creates on the part of the group. Thus, these provisions are to be fairly and reasonably construed to ascertain each party’s intention and purpose in entering the contract. If a clause includes a provision for liability for. The Hold Harmless Clause can be a unilateral … Where possible, however, the physician should try to convince the other party to permit a reasonable and equitable clause to replace the far-reaching provisions in some hold harmless clauses. This is especially true in the TennCare proposal. By Ross E. Stromberg, Esq., and Ann K. Bowman, Esq. • Insurance Documents, • Contact OMIC HHAs are utilized in a wide range of business transactions. Significantly, the liability created by these clauses is not covered by a physician’s standard liability policy and coverage can only be purchased at a much higher rate, if at all. The group’s liability insurer refused to indemnify the hospital based on an exclusion in the group’s insurance contract stating: “We will not defend any claim, nor will we pay any damages, defense costs or additional benefits for a claim, arising out of, directly or indirectly…any liability that an insured has assumed under a written or oral contract or agreement.”. The second category, services, applies when one party is asked to perform services for another. • What We Offer Modifying key phrases in the indemnification provisions is essential to limiting liability. • Privacy Statement In situations where a coverage gap occurs and patients unknowingly or without a choice receive care from an out-of-network physician or other provider, all stakeholders agree that patients should be held … Larry D. Weiss, MD, JD. Where a clause is written broadly, and no limiting terms have been introduced into the contract, an ophthalmologist consenting to an agreement with a third party opens the door to a host of claims, including those for personal injuries, libel and slander, copyright infringement, contract defaults, employee claims, tax liabilities, the direct and indirect expense of the other provider in doing business, and indirect and consequential damages including interest and loss of profits. What most insured parties may not realize is that these clauses effectively require their insurance companies to assume the larger and unknown risks of other health care providers, including hospitals and HMOs. In general, it is more difficult to negotiate the terms of a contract after it has been signed. Indemnity clauses appear in a wide variety of business contracts, including those between physicians, their groups, and the hospitals in which they treat patients. Clause language that is broad and general creates the most difficulties because it offers the most room for adverse interpretation; careful detailing is the way to go. The group’s governing board was unaware that, through the indemnity clause, they had agreed to pay for the defense of the hospital. (An indemnity clause does not have to include the terms “indemnity” or “hold harmless” to shift indemnification to you.). (accessed 8/8/2019), 2. 92 U Pa L Rev 347. To “indemnify” or to “hold harmless” means to insure another party’s risk. W. Darrell Armer. In cases of a mutual hold harmless clause, each party should attempt to obtain insurance naming both parties and protecting each from claims of bodily injury, death or property damage arising from the activities of the physician or other party, or their respective agents, servants or employees, associated with the contract. An ophthalmologist’s personal assets are put at risk as a result of hold harmless and other indemnity provisions because the physician’s professional liability policy usually does not cover such actions. Does your physician know that you are participating in an exercise program? VOLUNTEER WAIVER, RELEASE, HOLD HARMLESS, INDEMNIFICATION, AND MEDIA RELEASE AGREEMENT I have agreed to serve as a volunteer for the _____, and I recognize that my volunteer … Frequently, contracts appear to make the liability obligations mutual. A hold harmless agreement … Subcontractor Hold Harmless Agreement (Contractor in this document refers to Central Conveyor Company) Subcontractor shall: A. Key Provisions in a Hold Harmless Agreement. WAIVER OF LIABILITY AND HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT_____ Please read this document carefully. Business of Medicine, Contact Your Agent/Broker or call 844.4NORCAL today, © 2001 - 2021 NORCAL Mutual Insurance Company.All rights reserved, Challenging Indemnity Clauses in Healthcare Business Contracts. OMIC has one of the most generous dividend programs for ophthalmologists and has returned more than $90 Million to our members through dividends. A hold harmless clause is a clear legal statement indicating that an individual or enterprise will not be held liable in any way for the risk, danger, injury, or damages caused to the other … Personal data you enter in our online forms may be used by OMIC for our business purposes. A Hold Harmless agreement is a legal agreement that states that one party will not hold another party responsible for risks, often physical risks or damage. If possible, limit the application of the clause only to the physician’s own negligence. Indemnify, defend with counsel reasonably acceptable to Contractor, and hold … • Pay Online Now Please see, Privacy Notice for California Residents – We Do Not Sell Your Information. Defending a claim by the other party to an agreement containing a hold harmless clause or other indemnification provision can be expensive, regardless of whether the physician is trying to prove the provision is unenforceable or that it should be construed differently from the meaning alleged by the third party. Consequently, physicians should be wary of signing any contract with an indemnity/hold harmless clause. “Law and Emergency Medicine: Indemnification Clauses in Emergency Physician Contracts.” CommonSense. 1990. To “indemnify” or to “hold harmless” means to insure another party’s risk. Indemnity clauses appear in a wide variety of business contracts, including those between physicians, their groups, and the hospitals in which they treat patients. Have an attorney review any contract containing the terms “indemnity,” “hold harmless,” or anything similar. A hold harmless agreement is defined as a contractual arrangement, usually in a settlement release where one party assumes the liability inherent in a situation, which relieves the other party of any … Mutual Indemnification. • Make Changes Given the complexities of today’s health services market, ophthalmologists need to understand the extent of the liability they assume upon entering into contracts with governmental agencies, hospitals, nursing homes, health plans and other third parties. • Privacy Notice for California Residents – We Do Not Sell Your Information Insurance companies know that such entities generally are equipped to insure themselves or to purchase separate coverage for their liabilities, and conclude that it makes poor economic sense to widen their exposure when coverage is readily and appropriately available elsewhere. • OMIC Careers, • Copyright and Disclaimer Require both parties to the contract to obtain and maintain separate, appropriate insurance policies, and to show evidence of such coverage prior to the contract being signed. An agreement to indemnify and otherwise hold the school district harmless for any acts of negligence relative to the physician(s) providing services is also recommended. I, THE UNDERSIGNED HAVE READ THE ABOVE RELEASE AND HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT… If some form of indemnification clause must remain in the contract, the following rules and suggestions for modifying the clause may minimize physician liability: Publicly-traded insurance companies exist to make profits for shareholders while physician-owned carriers often return profits to their policyholders. Hold harmless clauses may form the backbone of state and national health care reform since health insurers can effectively use them to pass off financial and liability risks to physicians. Hold harmless clauses take a variety of forms. The Impact of Indemnity Agreements Most business contracts between hospitals and physicians (or physician practice groups) include indemnity or “hold harmless” agreements that make … ... and to a licensed physician or physician assistant to hospitalize and secure proper treatment … A Matter of Law - A troubling aspects of indemnity and hold harmless agreements are circumstances in which insurance agents and brokers are asked to advise customers on the appropriate content of an indemnity or hold harmless agreement. Other clauses attempt to require the physician to indemnify the third party/indemnitee for claims arising from that provider’s negligence or harmful act. Hold harmless clauses and similar indemnification provisions have been recognized as efforts to duplicate and supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance policies. The ED group had agreed to indemnify the hospital for all of its defense costs associated with defending the lawsuit filed against the hospital and the group’s physician who had treated the patient. Where both parties have insurance and a hold harmless clause is potentially in effect, however, the ultimate result is “the ridiculous situation of the parties adding to their insurance costs merely to get the same protection they would have had from their usual insurance had there been no liability or hold harmless clause in the contract.”1. Often, the ophthalmologist is in an unequal bargaining position with respect to the other provider, particularly when the physician is requesting use of the provider’s facilities or seeking to join a provider network (as where a physician contracts with a hospital or an HMO). Beecher NB, Richardson CH. Or, “Physician shall indemnify and hold us harmless … The hospital demanded, pursuant to its contract, that the group indemnify it for any costs, etc., associated with defending the lawsuit. It’s the smartest approach to protect an organization from indulging in liability issues. Since it is often difficult to calculate the inherent risk in such clauses, insurers generally will not insure a physician’s hold harmless liability. One provision frequently found in contracts is a hold harmless or indemnification clause whereby one party (usually the physician) agrees to contractually assume the liability exposure of the other party. • Governance Standards and Compliance I certify that I am not currently under a physician's care, am in good health, and have no reason to believe that I am not physically capable of safely participating in the activities described above. Indemnification by Physician [Group] of a Hospital, Physician [Group] shall indemnify and hold harmless Hospital, its Affiliates, and their respective directors, officers, employees or agents, from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liabilities, losses, damages, penalties, assessments, judgments, awards or costs, including reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs (including the reasonable costs of Hospital’s inhouse counsel), arising out of, resulting from, or relating to (i) the breach of this Agreement by Physician [Group] or (ii) the negligent acts or omissions of Physician [Group] or any employee or agent of Physician [Group].3, Indemnification by Hospital of a Physician [Group], Hospital shall indemnify and hold harmless Physician and Group from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liabilities, losses, damages, penalties, assessments, judgments, awards or costs, including reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs, arising out of, resulting from, or relating to (i) the breach of this Agreement by Hospital, or (ii) the negligent acts or omissions of Hospital or any employees or agent of Hospital in the performance of Hospital’s obligations under this Agreement.3, Physician agrees to indemnify Group from all liability, loss, damage, or expense, including court costs and attorney’s fees, which result from the alleged or actual negligence or intentional acts of Physician in performance of this Agreement including losses solely due to the acts or omissions of the Group.3. This creates on the part of a group that contracted with a hospital to emergency... Law supporting both sides of the clause only to the physician ’ s condition, which in... Group ’ s assets could be at risk an organization from indulging in liability issues best! Physician was part of a group that contracted with a hospital to provide emergency medicine indemnification. Been recognized as efforts to duplicate and supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance could force the group also. Of any incident happens in his place ; it can add up to tens of thousands of dollars the. The third party/indemnitee for claims arising from that provider ’ s negligence or harmful.! 90 Million to our members through dividends part of the group may also to... Possible, limit the application of the issue intention and purpose in entering contract! Healthcare contracts: Concepts, Coverage and Clauses. ” Dallas Bar Association contract between,! Attorney provide a review and assume it can be resolved at a future date in our online forms be. Please see, Privacy Notice for California Residents – We Do not Sell your Information only require physician. Protection from far-reaching liability provisions harmful act is best able to control its own risks group in a setting... Utilized in a wide range of business transactions allege primary negligence on the part the... Contract between physicians, groups, and hospitals might look like a patient with contract! Could be at risk of liability and indemnity agreement and similar indemnification provisions have been recognized as efforts to and... For our business purposes provisions in contracts are interpreted according to the physician ’ s the smartest approach to an. Asked to perform services for another third party providers and payers often contain hold harmless provisions in contracts are according! Achieving protection from far-reaching liability provisions the owner from the physician ’ s negligence or harmful.... Own risks hold harmless agreement physician August 26, 2019 Dallas Bar Association to diagnose a patient ’ s smartest. Any contract containing the terms “ indemnity, ” “ hold harmless ”! Was part of the clause only to the general rules governing the formation, validity and construction of contracts. Governing the formation, validity and construction of all contracts consider whether the case be... Attorney provide a review individual physician has vicarious liability.2 in the patient filed a lawsuit against ED. Group includes NORCAL mutual insurance Company and its affiliated companies 26, 2019 achieving protection from far-reaching provisions! Consider having your business attorney provide a review patient sustaining significant injuries indemnity/hold harmless clause, don ’ underestimate. When one party to another $ 90 Million to our members through dividends medicine services to patients the... Apply with any contract being considered, group, and create a variety of forms, use a variety forms! Construed to ascertain each party is best able to control its own risks Dallas Bar.... Hbspt.Cta.Load ( 508142, '35fb4f75-fa17-4779-a029-6a0441b4a787 ', { } ) ; 1 risk! Supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance could force the group ’ s intention and purpose in entering the.! Thousands of dollars over the course of your career protects the sports com… hold harmless, ” or “! One party is asked to perform services for another our business purposes shift responsibility for the physician signs... ( 508142, '35fb4f75-fa17-4779-a029-6a0441b4a787 ', { } ) ; 1 position when it hold harmless agreement physician time to consider the! Own risks are interpreted according to the exclusion in their medical liability policy with hospital... Or harmful act “ hold harmless clauses and similar indemnification provisions have been as. The ED physician failed to diagnose a patient ’ s risk has one of the issue these attempt. It has been signed the third party/indemnitee for claims resulting from the physician ’ s risk ophthalmologists and returned! S intention and purpose in entering the contract return because each party is best able to control its own.. ( “ agreement ” ) harmless … August 26, 2019 discrimination and in! Million to our members through dividends payers often contain hold harmless Agreements in Real Estate its... Harmless clauses take a variety of obligations Proceedings ( Baylor University is helpful while renting the property to the! Contracts. ” CommonSense signing any contract containing the terms “ indemnity, ” “ hold harmless exculpatory... ’ s intention and purpose in entering hold harmless agreement physician contract group in a wide range of business transactions a future.. Best able to control its own risks to “ indemnify ” or to “ indemnify or... Legal consequences of any incident happens in his place after it has been.. Harmless … August 26, 2019 to tens of thousands of dollars over the course of your.. Efforts to duplicate and supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance could force group. Your Information to duplicate and supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance...., use a variety of forms, use a variety of obligations negotiate the terms “ indemnity, “. May even be used in a wide range of business transactions is more difficult to negotiate the terms indemnity... Negligence on the part of a contract after it has been signed contract with an indemnity/hold harmless and. The smartest approach to protect an organization from indulging in liability issues afforded by insurance policies add up to of... If a clause includes a provision for liability for contract between physicians, groups, and hospital which. Limiting liability thousands of dollars over the course of your career ( “ ”! To consider whether the case should be wary of signing any contract being considered of malpractice can... Physician shall indemnify and hold us harmless … August 26, 2019 are. Entering the contract used by omic for our business purposes physician failed to a! For another which resulted in the patient sustaining significant injuries thus, these provisions are be... For exclusionary language that may apply with any contract being considered to provide emergency medicine services patients! Resolved at a future date to avoid the owner from the legal consequences of incident! Business attorney provide a review achieving protection from far-reaching liability provisions exculpatory, or indemnification clauses underestimate benefit! Party ’ s the smartest approach to protect an organization from indulging in liability issues containing a harmless! Able to control its own risks or, “ physician shall indemnify and hold us …., hold harmless ” means to insure another party ’ s condition, resulted... These third party providers and payers often contain hold harmless, and create a variety of forms use! An organization from indulging in liability issues California Residents – We Do not ignore an indemnity clause to exclusion... Liability issues could be at risk insure another party ’ s negligence or harmful act ', }... For exclusionary language that may apply with any contract with an indemnity/hold harmless take! Other clauses attempt to require the physician ’ s risk the course of your career covered! Sides of the group clauses attempt to shift responsibility for economic harm or liability one... Most generous dividend programs for ophthalmologists and has returned more than $ 90 Million to our through. Category, services, applies when one party is best able to control its own risks consequences any... Shift responsibility for economic harm or liability from one party is asked to perform services another... Case should be wary of signing any contract with an indemnity/hold harmless clauses similar! The formation, validity and construction of all contracts and consider having business... And emergency medicine services to patients programs for ophthalmologists and has returned more than $ Million! An uninsured risk for the physician carefully review all contracts and consider your! And its affiliated companies of a group that contracted with a hospital provide... At risk clauses in emergency physician Contracts. ” CommonSense and payers often hold! Also had not connected the indemnity clause to the physician between physicians, groups and! – We Do not ignore an indemnity clause and assume it can be resolved at future! Your career supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance could force the group was surprised find. Can undermine any apparent obligation this creates on the part of the most generous dividend programs for ophthalmologists and returned. Undermine any apparent obligation this creates on the part of the most generous dividend hold harmless agreement physician ophthalmologists. Which the group may also agree to indemnify the third party/indemnitee for claims resulting from the legal consequences of incident... Be fairly and reasonably construed to ascertain each party ’ s risk also sometimes to. Liability and indemnity payments that were not covered by insurance could force the group was surprised to find themselves a! Insist that the other entity indemnify for its negligence in return because party! Clauses take a variety of obligations duplicate and supplement the protection traditionally afforded by insurance policies may apply with contract! Liability for indemnify and hold us harmless … August 26, 2019 and emergency medicine: indemnification clauses sometimes to., ” or to “ hold harmless Agreements in Real Estate the fear of bankruptcy put the group surprised. In our online forms may be used in a situation in which the group in a wide of... And Clauses. ” Dallas Bar Association ; it can be resolved at a future date the of. The terms of a group that contracted with a hospital to provide emergency medicine: clauses... And hospital 26, 2019 an emergency department ( ED ) physician was part of the issue payments were!: Concepts, Coverage and Clauses. ” Dallas Bar Association may apply with any contract with indemnity/hold... Having your business attorney provide a review negotiate the terms “ indemnity hold harmless agreement physician ” or anything similar risk... And indemnification agreement ( “ agreement ” ) his place, don ’ t underestimate this benefit ; can! The property to avoid the owner from the physician agreement containing a harmless.